Raghda Hanna
Professor Rinke
Writing 150
October 26, 2011
They Say, I Say
Dave Eggers says in the article, “Serve Or Fail,” that colleges should be three year. He says, students do and do not deserve a time off because a good deal of the four years in college is spent playing foosball; and he says they do deserve a time off because finals week is stressful and they are sleep-deprived and possibly involves trucker-style stimulants. He says the many hours need killing, there was just too many; instead those hours should be for our communities in one way or another. He believes that colleges should consider instituting a service requirement for graduation. He wants colleges to give credit for service; a credit equals to one class period. What students will learn from all the volunteer work will sure equal the time that could be spent in a racquetball class. Dave Eggers uses his life examples to grab the reader’s attention, such as volunteering a few times in Urbana-Champaign – at a Y.M.C.A. and t home for senior citizens. These real life examples shelter his main points in the article. This article appeals to logic; he embodies his article with stats and facts about why school time should be reduces, why the time taken out should be put into the community, and how volunteer work will benefit a person.
Judith Ramaley says in the article, “’Service Learning’ More Than a Fad,” do more and spend less. Tight money is erasing many line items deemed nonessential from higher education budgets. In “service learning,” the compact encourages colleges to do takes many forms. This can help in education and career in the long run. Judith Ramaley also presents that; it’s not something you figure out how to do when you’ve got extra time. He believes that people should get involved, when they do their sense of purpose grows. The three main points in this article appeal to logic because it is stating the service learning in a trend. It also appeals to emotion because it gives out a feeling of happiness and success when ones improve their sense of purpose after doing something good for others. These three main points include, service learning and how it can be done in various ways, have real world experiences and improving one’s sense of purpose when it comes to helping the community.
The Monitor’s Editorial Board says in the article, “How to reduce student dropout rates: link volunteering to studies,” volunteering is up in American even in hard times. They say that service learning prevents kids from dropping out of school in his rural grape-growing district. People should start early, in elementary school he has them tend the school garden and hate trout for the depleted population in the San Joaquin River. In high school, they help immigrants study for citizenship tests. Also, service learning weaves volunteering with specific academic instruction. Students reflect on a project, not just check it off on their to-do list. The author here is appealing to ethics because it is in in a person’s belief to start to volunteer early or late. This also appeals to logic because it uses many stats that are backs up by examples. The three main point in this article are how volunteering should start at a young age, students will stay in school because of community work and how volunteering connect to academic success.
I think the three main points in all of the articles combined are dealing with volunteer work and its benefits. They are all focusing on volunteer work in school and how school hours should be cut back and volunteer work should be a requirement for graduation. I agree with having cutting back hours in college to volunteer in the community because I feel that I would benefit so much more from it, rather just to sit in an class I am not interested in to fulfill the graduation requirements. By not spending so much time in a class that has no meaning or affect to my future career, and me I could be out there volunteering and expanding my sense of purpose. I disagree with starting volunteer work at a young age and it being beneficial with academics success and keeping kids in school. Kids should be focused on school at a young age. They should have a feel for it and figure out for themselves in volunteer work will benefit them later on when they are older.
The three authors all agree that service leaning should be taking into consideration with everyone. They say that learning by volunteering will benefit you more because you are out there getting experience. Where they differ is that in one of the articles, they say that in college, volunteer work should be a requirement, where on the other hand in another article it says that volunteer work should start at a young age and keep growing. Also, one article brings up saving money, spending less. This differed from the other two articles.